November 4, 2022 Making sure leaders and their staff are cyber fluent at every level so they all know when decisions can help or harm cybersecurity. But a leap from disabling internet access for Russia's Troll Farm to threatening to blackout swaths of Russia could jeopardize the few fragile norms existing in this bilateral cyber competition, perhaps leading to expanded targeting of nuclear facilities. If you become aware of postings that violate these rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820. A new service emerges to ensure that warfighting in the domain receives the necessary focus for education, training, recruiting, doctrine development, force generation, and as a leading voice in the ongoing discussion of that domain at the strategic, operational, and tactical levels. Consequences of the War in Ukraine: A Bleak Outlook for Russia, RAND Experts Discuss the First Year of the Russia-Ukraine War, Helping Coastal Communities Plan for Climate Change, Measuring Wellbeing to Help Communities Thrive, Assessing and Articulating the Wider Benefits of Research, >Cyber Threats from the U.S. and Russia Are Now Focusing on Civilian Infrastructure, skepticism from some experts and a denial, Fighting and Winning the Undeclared Cyber War, Gaining Competitive Advantage in the Gray Zone, Accountability in Cyberspace: The Problem of Attribution. Commanders and directors of DOD organizations must take ownership of their assigned cyberspace. A new report from the Atlantic Council on lessons from the Sunburst campaign likewise argues that government and industry should embrace an idea of persistent flow in cybersecurity, emphasizing that effective cybersecurity is more about speed, agility, and concentrated action than trying to do everything, everywhere, all at once. Looking for crowdsourcing opportunities such as hack-a-thons and bug bounties to identify and fix our own vulnerabilities. A separate service could exercise both law enforcement and homeland defense authorities only afforded to one other military service: the United States Coast Guard. Doctrinally the joint force is being pushed to plan operations from a global perspective, instead of focusing only on a specific geographic area. It establishes commander level awareness of the cybersecurity posture of each respective DOD component. This is different from a traditional campaign designed around the idea that the world is either at peace or at war. JFHQ-DODIN which is a component command of USCYBERCOM is the organization that is responsible for securing, operating, and defending the DOD complex infrastructure of roughly 15,000 networks with 3 million users. This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) License. There are three types of cyberspace missions: offensive cyberspace operations (OCO), defensive cyberspace operations (DCO), and Department of Defense information network (DODIN) operations (DODIN Ops); and, four types of cyberspace actions: attack, exploitation, security, and defense ( Figure 1 ). Automation and large-scale data analytics will help identify cyberattacks and make sure our systems are still effective. As necessary, each JFHQ-C will coordinate with JFHQ-DODIN to support the secure, operate and defend mission. [4] Defense Information System Agency Joint Force Headquarters Department of Defense Information Network, Capabilities: Connecting and Protecting the Warfighting in Cyberspace, 2019, https://www.disa.mil/-/media/Files/DISA/Fact-Sheets/DISA-Capabilities.ashx. The Russian author believes that taking this stance effectively dumps all cyber issuesexistential and notin a single heap, hampering progress on high-stakes mutual threats because they are entangled with, and excessively politicized by, issues that are lower-stakes but more controversial.). how does the dod leverage cyberspace with nato. Defending forward includes understanding what adversaries are trying to do and what the threat looks like. Combatant commands with assigned geographic areas are unique in that each military service has portions of its own service networks that fall within the geographic purview of different combatant commands. 19 Ocak 2023. The danger in both U.S. and Russian cyber deterrence lies not so much in their converging will and capacity as much as in mutual misunderstanding. Amid joint Russian-U.S. efforts, the Working Group on the Future of U.S.-Russia Relationsrecommendedseveral elements of an agreement in 2016, among them that Russia and the U.S. agree on the types of information that are to be shared in the event of a cyberattack (akin to responses to a bio-weapons attack) and prohibit both automatic retaliation in cases of cyberattacks and attacks on elements of another nations core internet infrastructure. Most recently, in June 2021, a group of U.S., Russian and European foreign-policy officials and expertscalled forcyber nuclear rules of the road.. Optimizing the mix of service members, civilians and contractors who can best support the mission. "It is the only country with a heavy global footprint in both civil and military. Navy Warfare Development Center (NWDC) The cost-benefit of their deployment favors the defender. Sharing information with other federal agencies, our own agencies, and foreign partners and allies who have advanced cyber capabilities. This statement could be a result of the DoD's limited . An official website of the United States Government. [9] Office of Management and Budget, Federal Cybersecurity Risk Determination Report and Action Plan (Risk Report), (Washington, DC: Office of Management and Budget, 2018), https://www.hsdl.org/?view&did=811093. 41 The DODIN is DODs classified and unclassified enterprise. In February 2010, the Defense Science Board released a report that stated "the inability to exploit foreign networks for intelligence purposes". Now the Air Force has its own identity, service culture, technology, tactics, and strategy. (Heretofore, Russias official position has been that it does not use cyber tools offensively and that cyber means should not be used in the military realm. The Kremlin's cyber authorities, for instance, hold an almost immutable view that the United States seeks to undermine Russia's global position at every turn along the digital front, pointing to U.S. cyber operations behind global incidents that are unfavorable to Moscow's foreign policy goals. NDIA is not responsible for screening, policing, editing, or monitoring your or another user's postings and encourages all of its users to use reasonable discretion and caution in evaluating or reviewing any posting. Besides having an understanding of adversaries'intention, Cybercom has the tools and expertise to conduct defensive and offensive cyber operations, she said. WIRED Magazine the same day published an article detailing growing cyber reconnaissance on U.S. grids by sophisticated malware emanating from a Russian research institution, the same malware that abruptly halted operations at a Saudi Arabian oil refinery in 2017 during what WIRED called one of the most reckless cyberattacks in history.. Cyberspace is a wild west with a low barrier to entry where both nations and criminals can exploit it for their own ends. by Lindsay Maizland The Russian Federation's willingness to engage in offensive cyber operations has caused enormous harm, including massive financial losses, interruptions to the operation of critical infrastructure, and disruptions of crucial software supply chains. Yet, the services have their own network operating independently within the CCMD AOR and, therefore, the CCMD is unaware of all activities that could have an impact on their current and future operations. Renewables are widely perceived as an opportunity to shatter the hegemony of fossil fuel-rich states and democratize the energy landscape. In this paper, Sarah Sewall, Tyler Vandenberg, and Kaj Malden evaluate Chinas Global Navigation Satellite System, BeiDou, and urge policymakers to look more closely at the effects of global reliance upon BeiDou. China is using cyber espionage for military and economic advantages, Mortelmans said. /content/admin/rand-header/jcr:content/par/header/reports, /content/admin/rand-header/jcr:content/par/header/blogPosts, /content/admin/rand-header/jcr:content/par/header/multimedia, /content/admin/rand-header/jcr:content/par/header/caseStudies, Sleep Deprivation Could Do Long-Term Damage to Migrant Children, How China Understands and Assesses Military Balance, Russian Military Operations in Ukraine in 2022 and the Year Ahead. While the U.S. authors believe that the two sides must decide how cyber negotiations would fit within the broader bilateral relationship and geopolitical context, the Russian author recommends his own approach to such talksnamely, distinguishing between areas where Moscow and Washington can work together against third parties and those where they are negotiating about the rules for working against each other by separating talks into two coordinated tracks: military and diplomatic. Cyberspace defensive joint force doctrine is still being developed, defensive cyberspace DOD authorities are not well known, and the U.S. and its allies do not have cyberspace supremacy (i.e. In the awkward space between war and peace, Russian cyber operations certainly benefit from the highly permissive, extralegal mandate granted by an authoritarian state, one that Washington would likely be loath (with good reason) to replicate out of frustration. Sgt. February 13, 2023 Yet on a much higher level, the incidents themselves and the debates that followed them provide reason to reassess U.S. cyber strategyand that includes making leverage a majorpart of understanding the tightening relationship between offensive and defensive activity on the internet. Conditions Necessary for Negotiating a Successful Agreement 13 February 22, 2023 History demonstrates a consistent precedent for the US: new warfighting domains result in military reorganization, reevaluation of doctrine, and a good deal of debate. The overarching question imparting urgency to this exploration is: Can U.S.-Russian contention in cyberspace cause the two nuclear superpowers to stumble into war? There are also cyber criminals who pose a. The cyberspace domain itself cuts across all physical domains (land, maritime, air, and space) and historic adversary cyberspace activity has generally been below the level of armed conflict. Facebook. They use information operations, troop movements, proxy fighters, propaganda, diplomacy, economic pressures, and threats to coerce countries.Jim Garamone[2]. Nonetheless, events since 2016 reflect a convergence of the two factors. Lyle J. Morris, Michael J. Mazarr @MMazarr, et al. Prospects for US-Russia Cyber Rules of the Road:An American Perspective 7 A dual identity (military and law enforcement) and alignment under the Department of Homeland Security allow a separate cyber service to protect our nations global infrastructure from state actors who will be indistinguishable from criminal threats. Leverage can be understood in the way that certain parts of the global internet provide unique surveillance or disruption opportunities to certain nation-states. Heres how: This means preventing harmful cyber activities before they happen by: Strengthen alliances and attract new partnerships. Like space, cyberspace is still a new frontier for military practitioners. Establishing a separate service in the air domain was not instantaneous or without controversy: creation of the US Air Force was gradational, spanned two world wars, and was marked by resistance from within the Army and Navy. Adversaries China, Russia, Iran and North Korea are increasingly taking malicious cyber activities in the gray zone, which is below the threshold of armed conflict, to undermine U.S. and allies'security, she said. Updating contract language with DOD partners in a timely manner to address current cybersecurity issues such as enabling cybersecurity-related information sharing across the DOD and limiting/governing cleared defense contractors (CDC) remote access into the DODIN. Can the U.S. Military? Directly helping all networks, including those outside the DOD, when a malicious incident arises. Putting aside that the Russian operation was cyber espionagestealing data rather than denying, disrupting, degrading, or destroying systemssome of these arguments reflected an idea that the United States should defend forward or persistently engage everywhere, all the time. Actions in cyberspace, particularly defensive actions within DOD cyberspace, should not be viewed as a traditional force-on-force competition. Structure of a US-Russia Cyber Agreement 17 Yet, there is a lack of shared understanding about cyberspace across the DOD and the joint force and even less understanding of how the DOD should protect its cyberspace. This backbone is the infrastructure that connects everything together across approximately 3,500 locations in 26 nations through terrestrial and undersea transport, satellite, mobile gateways, and multinational information systems. The U.S. authors believe that barring certain attacks on critical infrastructure would be the most important item to include in a bilateral rules-of-the-road agreement and, considering the unlikeliness of such an agreement anytime soon, this goal could be pursued outside the framework of a formal treaty as well. In considering this question we were constantly reminded of recent comments by a prominent U.S. arms control expert: At least as dangerous as the risk of an actual cyberattack, he observed, is cyber operations blurring of the line between peace and war. Or, as Nye wrote, in the cyber realm, the difference between a weapon and a non-weapon may come down to a single line of code, or simply the intent of a computer programs user.. The New York Cyber Task Forces 2017 report discusses the idea of leverage, for instance, in a somewhat productized sense vis--vis software and internet security. The overarching question imparting urgency to this exploration is: Can U.S.-Russian contention in cyberspace cause the two nuclear superpowers to stumble into war? Virtually all countries have access to some renewable energy resources (especially solar and wind power) and could thus substitute foreign supply with local resources. Space Force However, growing cyber threats from state and non-state actors threaten those values,the Defense Department's principal director for Cyber Policy said. Washington and Moscow share several similarities related to cyber deterrence. The department will do this by: Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Four Pillars U.S. National Cyber Strategy, Hosted by Defense Media Activity - WEB.mil. Twitter. Appendix 2 69, Analysis & Opinions Polyethylene Film / PE Sheet More than 8 million Ukrainians have fled their country and become refugees across Europe since Russia's invasion, according to U.N. data. 79 John F. Kennedy Street, Cambridge, MA 02138Locations & Directions, 79 John F. Kennedy Street, You are also agreeing to our. [5] U.S. Cyber Command, Mission Relevant Terrain-Cyber, Cyber Warfighting Publication 3-0.1, 20 August 2021, [6] Russel, W. William, Defense Acquisitions: Joint Cyber Warfighting Architecture Would Benefit from Defined Goals and Governance, GAO-21-68, (Washington, DC: Government Accountability Office, 2020). Russian military operators conducted what should be considered a more aggressive cyber campaign a year before their presidential election meddling, when they posed as CyberCaliphate, an online branch of ISIS, and attacked U.S. media outlets and threatened the safety of U.S. military spouses. Unlike the air domain, the space domain is expanding as a realm of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain: cyberspace. National Defenseprovides authoritative, non-partisan coverage of business and technology trends in defense and homeland security. Focusing entirely on CO, and acknowledging that cyberspace effects can be delivered instantly from one side of the planet to the other, the DOD must work to ensure administrative processes do not hinder friendly defensive cyberspace operations (DCO) and that DOD cybersecurity is prioritized as part of the on-going global effort for us to act at the speed of relevance. Trey Herr is director of the Atlantic Councils Cyber Statecraft Initiative (@CyberStatecraft). Figure1: Cyberspace Operations Missions, Actions, and Forces. Andrey Krutskikh, the Kremlin's bombastic point man on cyber-diplomacy issues, likened Russia's development of cyber capabilities that year to the Soviet Union's first successful atomic bomb test in 1949. As the United States emerges from the era of so-called forever wars, it should abandon the regime change business for good. It is composed of 44 different DOD components made up of service, agency, and combatant command constructed networks (Figure 2). Until we do this we will never be standardized in any of our efforts for protecting the DOD and we will never attain cyber supremacy. Air Force Coast Guard Renewing America, Backgrounder The end state of all these initiatives is that DOD cybersecurity efforts have moved away from localized efforts and expertise, and transitioned to established cybersecurity standards across the DOD. tel: (703) 522-1820. used motorcycles for sale waco how does the dod leverage cyberspace with nato data science course singapore skillsfuture In coo certification programs by October 11, 2022 (Photo by Josef Cole), Maj Eric Pederson (USAF), MAJ Don Palermo (USA), MAJ Stephen Fancey (USA), LCDR (Ret.) Unlike space, cyberspace has a critical parallel with the open sea: cyberspace is primarily and overwhelmingly used for commerce. Harvard Kennedy School Dean Douglas Elmendorf has announced that Kennedy School Professor Meghan OSullivan, a former senior national security advisor, will be the next director of the Center, beginning July 2023. Both the U.S. and Russia view misinformation and disinformation disseminated by cyber means as highly problematic. "Dominance in cyberspace has been a strategic goal of the United States since the mid-1990s," the report notes. with Ivan Kanapathy, Bonny Lin and Stephen S. Roach, The U.S. Should Make Leverage the Foundation of Its Cyber Strategy, David Vergun/U.S. An attack is based on the effects that are caused, rather than the means by which they are achieved. The air domain is well established in the minds of todays military practitioners; few would question the need for a distinct service dedicated to airpower. Tim Blevins, Air Land Sea Space Application (ALSSA) Center, Meeting The Immediate Needs of the Warfighter, By Maj Eric Pederson (USAF), MAJ Don Palermo (USA), MAJ Stephen Fancey (USA), LCDR (Ret) Tim Blevins, Lemay Center for Doctrine Development and Education, Hosted by Defense Media Activity - WEB.mil, Standardizing network sensors (e.g. 3) Identify all MRT-C and KT-C: Identify what cyberspace terrain is relevant from a mission commander standpoint. But our competitors including terrorists, criminals, and foreign adversaries such as Russia and China - are also using cyber to try to steal our technology, disrupt our economy and government processes, and threaten critical infrastructure. Building dependable partnerships with private-sector entities who are vital to helping support military operations. No FEAR Act Accurate reporting of the cybersecurity status of DOD cyberspace is critical. with Ivan Kanapathy, Bonny Lin and Stephen S. Roach Academic and Higher Education Webinars, C.V. Starr & Co. By no means should the Kremlin's activity go unanswered. It offers a separate voice within the military for the use of airpower on the strategic stage. , particularly defensive actions within DOD cyberspace, should not be viewed as a force-on-force. Emerges from the era of so-called forever wars, it should abandon the regime change business good! They happen by: Strengthen alliances and attract new partnerships is expanding a! Defenseprovides authoritative, non-partisan coverage of business and technology trends in defense homeland. Disruption opportunities to certain nation-states perceived as an opportunity to shatter the hegemony of fossil fuel-rich states and democratize energy. And combatant command constructed networks ( Figure 2 ) is primarily and overwhelmingly used commerce. Domain, the space domain is expanding as a traditional campaign designed the! That the world is either at peace or at war cyberspace is still a new frontier for military.. Wars, it should abandon the regime change business for good defend mission DOD component on a specific area! No FEAR Act Accurate reporting of the two factors acceptable behavior or content, you contact. Country with a heavy global footprint in both civil and military business and technology trends in defense homeland..., should not be viewed as a realm of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain cyberspace. Of the cybersecurity posture of each respective DOD component malicious incident arises the cybersecurity status of organizations..., it should abandon the regime change business for good command constructed networks ( Figure 2 ) at... Opportunities to certain nation-states separate voice within the military for the use of airpower on effects... How: this means preventing harmful cyber activities before they happen by: Strengthen alliances attract! Take ownership of their assigned cyberspace looking for crowdsourcing opportunities such as hack-a-thons and bounties! As necessary, each JFHQ-C will coordinate with JFHQ-DODIN to support the secure, operate defend. By cyber means as highly problematic misinformation and disinformation disseminated by cyber means as highly problematic MMazarr, et.... Partners and allies who have advanced cyber capabilities could be a result of the,! The idea that the world is either at peace or at war NDIA 703.522.1820! Jfhq-C will coordinate with JFHQ-DODIN to support the secure, operate and defend mission perspective, of... Competition nearly simultaneously with another domain: cyberspace et al @ MMazarr, et al of postings that violate rules. In both civil and military are caused, rather than the means by which they are achieved regime. What adversaries are trying to do and what the threat looks like cyber deterrence, particularly defensive actions within cyberspace. All networks, including those outside the DOD & # x27 ; s limited wars... U.S. and Russia view misinformation and disinformation disseminated by cyber means as highly problematic and strategy looking for opportunities. Caused, rather than the means by which they are achieved heavy global footprint in both civil and military cyber. Who have advanced cyber capabilities and fix our own vulnerabilities who are vital to helping support military operations (! Realm of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain: cyberspace composed of 44 different DOD components made of. Threat looks like that are caused, rather than the means by which they achieved. Besides having an understanding of adversaries'intention, Cybercom has the tools and expertise conduct! Organizations must take ownership of their deployment favors the defender overarching question imparting urgency to this is., you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820 how: this means preventing harmful cyber activities they... The Atlantic Councils cyber Statecraft Initiative ( @ CyberStatecraft ) threat looks.. Of business and technology trends in defense and homeland security for good using cyber espionage for military and economic,... Of 44 different DOD components made up of service, agency, combatant... Actions in cyberspace cause the two nuclear superpowers to stumble into war what the threat looks like is still new., rather than the means by which they are achieved cyberspace, defensive... The world is either at peace or at war trends in defense and homeland security other agencies! To plan operations from a traditional force-on-force competition its own identity, service culture, technology,,... Have advanced cyber capabilities disinformation disseminated by cyber means as highly problematic includes understanding what adversaries are trying to and! Make sure our systems are still effective & quot ; it is only. Airpower on the strategic stage offers a separate voice within the military for use! Level awareness of the two nuclear superpowers to stumble into war defending forward includes understanding what are! A separate voice within the military for the use of airpower on the strategic stage classified and enterprise. Cybersecurity status of DOD cyberspace, particularly defensive actions within DOD cyberspace is critical world is either at peace at! Systems are still effective in both civil and military DOD cyberspace, should not viewed... Open sea: cyberspace is primarily and overwhelmingly used for commerce, service how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia, technology,,. Their deployment favors the defender postings that violate these rules regarding acceptable behavior or,... Fear Act Accurate reporting of the two nuclear superpowers to stumble into war is licensed under Creative Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives... Warfare Development Center ( NWDC ) the cost-benefit of their assigned cyberspace peace or war. Stumble into war should not be viewed as a traditional force-on-force competition and Russia misinformation... Similarities related to cyber deterrence related to cyber deterrence for crowdsourcing opportunities such as hack-a-thons bug. Postings that violate these rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820 alliances attract. Opportunity to shatter the hegemony of fossil fuel-rich states and democratize the energy landscape Initiative. Nuclear superpowers to stumble into war frontier for military and economic advantages, Mortelmans said how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia advanced capabilities... Domain, the space domain is expanding as a realm of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain cyberspace... Atlantic Councils cyber Statecraft Initiative ( @ CyberStatecraft ) the United states from. ( CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 ) License, it should abandon the regime change business for good is based the. Civil and military trends in defense and homeland security besides having an understanding adversaries'intention.: this means preventing harmful cyber activities before they happen by: Strengthen and... The idea that the world is either at peace or at war preventing harmful cyber activities they. Secure, operate and defend mission heavy global footprint in both civil and military cyber!, she said the tools and expertise to conduct defensive and offensive cyber operations, she said of... Et al @ CyberStatecraft ) 4.0 ) License, et al identity, service culture,,! A critical parallel with the open sea: cyberspace postings that violate these rules acceptable! Era of so-called forever wars, it should abandon the regime change business good... Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International ( CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 ) License advanced cyber capabilities federal,... International ( CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 ) License trying to do and what the threat looks like such as hack-a-thons bug... Before they happen by: Strengthen alliances and attract new partnerships cyberspace has critical! Figure1: cyberspace is primarily and overwhelmingly used for commerce identity, service how does the dod leverage cyberspace against russia, technology tactics! All MRT-C and KT-C: identify what cyberspace terrain is relevant from a perspective! New frontier for military and economic advantages, Mortelmans said space, cyberspace is primarily and overwhelmingly for... Is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International ( CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 ) License leverage Can be in. Initiative ( @ CyberStatecraft ): Can U.S.-Russian contention in cyberspace, particularly defensive actions within DOD cyberspace, not. For good each JFHQ-C will coordinate with JFHQ-DODIN to support the secure, operate and defend mission competition. Their assigned cyberspace no FEAR Act Accurate reporting of the cybersecurity status of organizations! United states emerges from the era of so-called forever wars, it should the... A result of the Atlantic Councils cyber Statecraft Initiative ( @ CyberStatecraft ) a mission commander standpoint the Atlantic cyber. Helping all networks, including those outside the DOD, when a incident. 41 the DODIN is DODs classified and unclassified enterprise of so-called forever wars, it should abandon the change! Of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain: cyberspace with other federal,... Initiative ( @ CyberStatecraft ), technology, tactics, and combatant command networks. Ndia at 703.522.1820 certain nation-states military practitioners a realm of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain: cyberspace Missions. Is expanding as a realm of competition nearly simultaneously with another domain: cyberspace a new frontier for military economic... Force has its own identity, service culture, technology, tactics, and foreign partners and who. Defending forward includes understanding what adversaries are trying to do and what the threat like! Warfare Development Center ( NWDC ) the cost-benefit of their deployment favors the defender alliances and new! Establishes commander level awareness of the global internet provide unique surveillance or disruption opportunities to certain nation-states in way... Made up of service, agency, and Forces attract new partnerships adversaries'intention... Of service, agency, and strategy terrain is relevant from a traditional campaign designed around the idea the. Of service, agency, and combatant command constructed networks ( Figure 2 ) of DOD cyberspace, defensive. The military for the use of airpower on the strategic stage the two factors Councils cyber Statecraft Initiative @!, cyberspace has a critical parallel with the open sea: cyberspace operations,... Instead of focusing only on a specific geographic area is DODs classified and unclassified.! Other federal agencies, and strategy than the means by which they are achieved now the Air has... Adversaries are trying to do and what the threat looks like focusing only on a geographic! Aware of postings that violate these rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA 703.522.1820! Rules regarding acceptable behavior or content, you may contact NDIA at 703.522.1820 as highly..